Spider-Man: Brand New Day – Review

In the year of our Lord 2026, it would be redundant to regurgitate Marvel’s failings since Endgame. So I’ll be brief. While the second three phases, The Multiverse Saga, produced the occasional highlight, in this era we have watched some of the outright worst Marvel films to date alongside underwhelming efforts that fell short of their hype. The dedication to churning out content for Disney+ not only watered down quality, but it also overwhelmed audiences with a barrage of content that even die-hards struggled to keep up with. One particular highlight of Phase 4 was Spider-Man: No Way Home, making it three well-received solo movies for the webslinger since joining the MCU. While Marvel struggles to course-correct its vision, Brand New Day was eyed with curiosity. The inclusion of Jon Bernthal’s Punisher/Frank Castle raised eyebrows, with sceptics questioning how the ultra-violent vigilante, previously grounded in realism, would integrate into the kid-friendly comic book world.  Could Marvel allow Brand New Day to stand on its own, or would they be compelled to overbloat the script to set up the upcoming Doomsday?

Four years have passed since Doctor Strange’s spell erased any knowledge of Peter Parker from the world. Alone, without friends, family, or personal identity, Peter has immersed himself in his alter ego – the only part of him still remembered in this new reality. While dealing with non-Avengers-level threats (“small potatoes”), he crosses paths with a dangerous telepath (Sadie Sink), whose vengeance threatens to destroy all he holds dear. Compounded by the trauma of living with Strange’s spell, Peter’s arachnid DNA mutates, manifesting a volatile part of him that might prove to be his greatest threat.

Tom Holland has no shortage of great villains to go up against, and thankfully that trend continues. Sink threatens to steal the show as the enigmatic adversary, her motives shrouded in as much mystery as her identity. Her ability to pivot from direct coldness to brutal fury makes her the most compelling villain Marvel has unveiled in years. Mark Ruffalo’s Bruce Banner makes a guest appearance, adding more superpowered madness, which brings us to the elephant in the room: Frank Castle. Introduced during a high-speed chase (one that locals to my own home city of Glasgow might recognise), his instant chemistry with Holland makes for a fun odd couple. No doubt cynics will pearl-clutch at a toned-down Punisher; the script doesn’t soften him…much. Yes, there are more comedic beats than we’re used to seeing with the character; however, he is still trigger-happy, even if the rating prevents him from going on a bloody rampage. Rest assured, you can still see it in his eyes.

A recent trend of superhero movies is dealing with grief. For Peter, he is not only dealing with the loss of Aunt May but also with the loss of his relationships with MJ (Zendaya) and Ned (Jacob Batalon). There is a special kind of pain associated with losing someone who is still alive. In Peter’s case, the hurt is amplified by the fact that they don’t even know who he is. He tortures himself by watching them go about their life, even attending their housewarming, while knowing that he can never get from them what he needs: recognition. Comparing this to the grief that Castle endures provides an interesting contrast and one that lends depth to Peter’s struggle with his identity and the monster within him.

This is a spectacle-filled action movie, so don’t expect a grounded character study devoid of set pieces.  The movie delivers on some thrilling action, working best when CGI is used to enhance the practical stunts, not replace them. Unfortunately, some of the CGI and green screen are noticeable enough that it takes you out of the film momentarily. It is to be expected that blockbuster movies become special effects extravaganzas, yet studios haven’t learned lessons from films such as Jurassic Park and Terminator 2, which still look incredible after thirty years. Compare it to many modern big-budget franchises that date before the credits roll.

Still, it’s not enough to drag the film down and overall, Brand New Day makes it a clean run of hits for Tom Holland’s Spider-Man. Even with a supporting cast of fellow heroes, this feels like a Spider-Man movie – one with a pleasantly contained story that, although it hints at what’s to come, isn’t consumed by it. Doomsday is as inevitable as the Marvel juggernaut, with many more projects announced for the coming years. With great power comes great responsibility; for the sake of audiences, hopefully Marvel heeds this.

Thomas Simpson
Follow me
Latest posts by (see all)

Leave a Reply

This site uses Akismet to reduce spam. Learn how your comment data is processed.