Love him or loathe him, Eli Roth is a big personality in horror. While there is no doubting his passion for the genre, opinions of his craft are more divisive. His brand of “gorno” reached a mainstream audience when it was more suited to the video nasty era. Over his career, he has been completely unhinged with Knock Knock (even Keanu Reeves couldn’t refuse free pizza), uninspired with his Death Wish remake and oddly subdued with his family-friendly The House With a Clock in Its Walls. Thanksgiving (based on a fake trailer he made twenty years earlier) is arguably his best work, with Roth learning when to rein it in and ramp it up to produce a crowd-pleasing slasher. Borderlands was infamously plagued by studio interference, and Ice Cream Man is a response to that. Released via his own production company, The Horror Section, Roth vows to “make the kind of hardcore horror films that fans want…without big studio interference.” Do audiences need Eli Roth unleashed in 2026? Do fans even want it?
The plot of Ice Cream Man is simple. One day, a mysterious and creepy vendor (Ari Millen) rolls up and sells the kids some treats. All seems normal enough until they start murdering all the adults within their vicinity. Thankfully for Jared (Charlie Zeltzer), he’s lactose intolerant, therefore free from consuming the brainwashing tools. Seeking others also unaffected, Jared and his group try to figure out how to stop the slaughter before it is too late.
Online backlash to the movie has seen everything from the script, style and director’s politics attacked. The cardinal sin for many is Roth’s admitted use of generative AI. Roth originally denied this, only to say he “misspoke”, admitting it was used but not saying how. Knowing this as you go into the movie, it becomes a focus point as your eye starts questioning every digital-looking effect. The use of AI seems needless when you consider the great use of practical effects for the deaths. As expected, they’re inventive and gratuitous, as Roth appears to be having fun directing a bunch of children to massacre their elders. However, despite his proclamations, this isn’t Roth at his worst. In the post-Terrifier world, and even in relation to his earlier works, Ice Cream Man fails to be as provocative as perhaps the director wishes.
Granted, the script will elicit groans as some of the dialogue is at best in bad taste. Roth and co-writer Noah Bels use the R word as an acceptable slur, while using an eating disorder as a punchline comes across as lazy as it is gross. Still, it seems strangely apt that a movie with such sophomoric humour would be said by, well, kids. This isn’t a defence by any means, but neither is it enough to have all copies of the film burned. The kid actors are fun to watch, and produce some fine performances. Millen himself as our titular villain doesn’t get much chance to shine, but haunts the film with a background menace as the kids take the spotlight.
At times the movie feels like it could be a deranged episode of Eerie Indiana, with its colourful palette painting the white picket fences of American suburbia with claret. The lack of substance means the concept does seem stretched out, even over its short runtime. A background exposition sequence goes on too long, even if that is part of the joke, as the attention span of our pre-teen heroes means they struggle to follow what’s happening.
The end product is a watchable horror movie that doesn’t push any boundaries or make you think or feel too hard. The kills are fun, and the young actors do a good job, but other than that, it’s fairly generic splatter horror. With a shortened runtime, it would easily slot into an anthology series and possibly be stronger for it. Overrated or overhated, Roth is certainly divisive, but it is unlikely that Ice Cream Man is what he is remembered for. It could be a cult favourite, and it could as easily fade into obscurity. Unless it benefits from The Streisand Effect, it is likely to be the latter.
- The Death of Robin Hood – Review - September 14, 2026
- Ice Cream Man (2026) – Review - August 5, 2026
- Spider-Man: Brand New Day – Review - August 3, 2026